The idea came up in one of my boards to rank the Final Fantasy series. It’s an exercise I haven’t done since a few of them came out, I believe. Here goes, from worst to best:
Final Fantasy II - Trash. The story does not hold up well at all, and the character development system is tedious, at best. There’s really not much to like about this game.
Final Fantasy - The original, but obviously unrefined. Still better than some of the slop that passes for RPGs these days, though. I’d still argue that the original Dragon Quest was better.
Final Fantasy IX - A return to the series’ roots, but a bad homage in my opinion. So much of this game was just uninspired, and the loading times just killed it for me. Sometimes I feel like I shouldn’t dislike this game as much as I do, but yet…
Final Fantasy VIII - Very odd storyline, but it’s the Junction system that made this game bad. Difficult to figure out at first, easy to break once you did. Primary villain was dumb, too. Notable for being the first title with really amazing videos.
Final Fantasy V - Still in the realm of games I didn’t like. The game handled summons well and the job system was fun, but the plot was pretty bad, and amazingly, the game didn’t look as good as IV did.
Final Fantasy VII - Great gameplay, and not so much else. Flashy presentation obscures an otherwise weird storyline. The first game to have a contemporary setting, and doesn’t necessarily hold up well as a result. Even still, this really was a Cloud vs. Sephiroth game, and couldn’t convincingly tie it to greater world conflict, as is typical for the series.
Final Fantasy X - No real complaints about this one, aside from killing the world map system. Fun combat, great storytelling, good artwork.
Final Fantasy III - Best game no one played. If you have a DS, pick this up. While there are some plot holes here and there, this was easily the best of the NES titles. Great music, good combat system, and not just the typical dungeon grind. The last three hours of the game have some of the best parts of the series.
Final Fantasy VI - Did just about everything right. The cataclysm was beyond anything seen in the art form until that point, and the only game in the series until XII to have a form of sandbox gameplay. Only marred by a very unlikely villain.
Final Fantasy IV - Probably not better on a technical level than VI, but a damn good game. Probably the first true incarnation of the series as we know it, and responsible for just about all of the Final Fantasy archetypes we see today. All of this game’s elements were well refined (after a second translation, that is).
Can’t really rank XII yet, but I can definitely say so far that it is among the higher end. Really well done so far, even if the combat does take some getting used to.